Woman working on her laptop in her living room.

NURTURING LEADS

SECTION 2

LEAD OUTREACH AND MANAGEMENT

AYA’s lead management philosophy empowers our team to serve as mission ambassadors. Local Coordinators are dedicated to fostering meaningful connections within the community and sharing the rewarding experiences of hosting. As facilitators, coordinators guide prospective volunteer host parents through the journey of becoming part of our program.

While these strategies are traditionally associated with sales, our approach focuses on building relationships and promoting our mission rather than products. By applying proven lead management techniques, our team ensures effective outreach and engagement, nurturing connections and inspiring involvement in our cause.

WHAT IS A LEAD?

A lead is someone who:

• Is interested in hosting an exchange student, now or in the future.

• Has shown interest in the program by completing our online registration form and creating an AYA website login.

• Has been entered by a Local Coordinator into the system for follow-up as a prospective host family.

• Was referred to AYA by a host family, student or acquaintance.

Your goal is to provide leads with excellent customer service, compelling program details and to encourage them to complete the AYA Host Family Application.

YOUR LEADS PORTAL

You can access your leads at any time through your LC portal. These leads remain on your list until you’ve contacted them and marked the task as complete. For a comprehensive list, go to the “My territory” tab, then click on “Leads.” Here, you can search, filter, and download leads. You can also add your own leads, review lead history, and document contact.

Check your leads daily and reach out promptly. Quick contact increases the likelihood of conversion.

Host families value responsiveness when selecting an agency. Building a rapport, demonstrating your responsiveness, and establishing expertise early on enhance the chances of families choosing you and AYA.

PRO TIP!

Make lead outreach a daily habit. Before your day gets busy, check your leads, reach out to new ones, and follow up with older leads in your pipeline.

LEAD NURTURING STRATEGY – DAY 1 AND BEYOND

Leads convert at varying speed, but most leads will take several weeks or longer to convert. Let’s talk about how to fill that window with meaningful outreach that gets results.

Things to keep in mind:

Be Prompt

Make contact as soon as that lead comes in. Some studies have shown that 5 minutes is the ideal response time – and while that may not always be feasible, the point is – the sooner you reach out, the more likely you are to connect with your lead!

Be First!

Aim to respond to emails, calls, and messages ASAP and always within 24 hours. Research shows customers now expect a nearly instantaneous response (5 minutes being an ideal time!). Even a brief acknowledgment like, “I received your message and am working to provide you with a response,” demonstrates your commitment to timely communication and fosters trust.

Follow Up Quickly

You can set follow-up reminders on your LC portal or other task management system.

Be Patient and Persistent

Remember, your leads might not be ready to commit right away – that’s ok! Your goal is to be top of mind when they are ready to search for an AYA. Lead engagement means playing the “long game” … your follow up will pay off down the road.

INITIAL OUTREACH

As soon as you receive a lead (and no later than the next day), contact them via email, phone, and text and encourage the lead to complete the host family application.

ENGAGEMENT WITH A LIVE PERSON:

When reaching out, engage in a conversation with open-ended questions:

“Hello! Is this X? This is (LC Name) from (City Name), representing Academic Year in America. I noticed your interest in hosting an AYA, and I’m here answer any questions you may have about the program”

Ask questions such as:

  • What motivated you to consider hosting an exchange student?
  • Can you tell me about your previous experiences hosting guests or students?
  • How do you envision the exchange student integrating into your family’s daily routines and activities?
  • What qualities or characteristics are you hoping the exchange student will bring to your household?
  • What concerns or reservations do you have about hosting an exchange student?
  • What types of activities or interests does your family enjoy participating in together?

Encourage the host family to log on to the student portal and check out available students. Offer to send the family a few profiles via email and establish a time to follow up to review those profiles – let them know that there’s no commitment to browse students and that you’re available to support them through ever step of the matching process!

Leave a message: Messages should be short and sweet!

“Hi, this is (LC Name) from Academic Year in America, calling for (lead name). I noticed your inquiry about hosting an AYA student—I am here to answer any questions you may have.  I’ll follow up with a text and email as well. My number is (LC number). Feel free to reach out to me however you prefer.”

Remember: Record call/message details in the LC portal for transparency.

Texting is a great way to support your lead outreach efforts. We know that most people now screen their phone calls – sending a follow up text after you call is a great way to establish your identity, verify that you are a real person who wants to support them, and offer the individual another mode of communication and opportunity to connect.

  • Text one lead at a time. Do not group text leads.
  • After leaving a voicemail or speaking on the phone, proceed with a follow-up email.
  • Text messages sent to prospects result in a 40% higher conversion rate.
  • Following up with a text message can significantly boost lead conversion
  • However, texting prospects before making phone contact decreases the likelihood of reaching them by up to 39%.
  • Always honor requests to discontinue texting.
  • Want some inspiration? Check out this video on texting host family leads.

Tips to craft an engaging email:

  • Customize the subject line to grab attention (e.g., “Discover AYA in Round Rock”).
  • Subject lines play a crucial role, as 33% of recipients open emails based solely on them.
  • Subject lines longer than a few words experience a significant drop in open rates, by over 60%.
  • Personalized emails, including the recipient’s first name in the subject line, can boost open rates by nearly 30%.
  • Use an emoji in the headline –emojis in the subject line tend to increase open rates!
  • Keep the subject lines short and sweet.
  • Personalize the email by mentioning the lead’s name and location.
  • Keep the content concise, utilizing bullet points for clarity.
  • Provide a clear call to action, including a link to apply and an offer to schedule a meeting.
  • Include a testimonial from a satisfied host family.
  • Include a link to one of AYA’s social media posts or YouTube videos

PERSONALIZE, PERSONALIZE, PERSONALIZE!

Personalization is the “secret sauce” when it comes to lead management and engagement. Personalized messaging demonstrates genuine interest and care, increasing the likelihood of engagement and response from leads. The benefits of personalization include:

  • Improved Customer Engagement: Research indicates that personalized marketing leads to higher levels of customer engagement.
  • Increased Conversion Rates: Personalized emails can significantly increase conversion rates.
  • Enhanced Customer Experience: Personalized outreach contributes to a better overall customer experience. Up to 80% of consumers are more likely to make a purchase when brands offer personalized experiences.
  • Higher Return on Investment (ROI): Personalization can lead to a higher ROI on marketing campaigns. Studies suggest that up to 60% of customers make decisions based on the level of personalization used by the organization or representative.

Examples of personalized follow-up emails could include:

  • Referencing specific details shared by the lead during initial contact, such as their interest in cultural exchange or hosting experiences.
  • Tailoring the email content to address the lead’s individual needs or concerns, showcasing how the program aligns with their goals.
  • Using the lead’s name and highlighting shared values or experiences to create a more personalized and relatable message.
Man in front of his laptop speaking on a cell phone.

FAST FACTS FOR OPTIMIZING LEAD MANAGEMENT!

  • Schedule specific time slots for calling leads during optimal hours, such as 10 am – 12 pm and 4 pm – 7 pm.
  • Aim for 6-8 call attempts per lead before deprioritizing.
  • 95% of successful first conversations happen by the sixth call.
  • Avoid giving up too soon; 44% of representatives quit after just one follow-up, while many prospects report wanting continued follow-up until they are ready or are no longer interested.
  • Don’t lose hope: 92% of representatives abandon efforts after no response on the 4th call, missing potential opportunities.
  • Keep trying: 75% of online prospects prefer at least 4 phone calls before contact stops, and many prefer to be contacted until they are ready to take the next step or withdraw interest.
  • Follow up with web leads within 5 minutes increases engagement 9X. Respond within 1 hour if 5 minutes is not possible.
  • Schedule lead generation emails strategically: email opens peak after 12 p.m., especially between 2 PM and 5 PM.
  • Consider timing: Tuesdays see the highest email open rates compared to other weekdays. However, do not wait to send or reply to emails, ever. Avoid calling during Mondays from 6 AM to noon and Friday afternoons UNLESS a host family lead has registered as a lead or contacted you about the program.
  • Differentiate by Lead Source: Acknowledge referral sources, craft compelling messages, and engage leads through personalized communication.
  • Enhance Email Open Rates: Use emojis strategically in subject lines and tailor messages to recipient interests.
  • Maximize Facebook Group Engagement: Incorporate visual content, share information, and encourage discussions. Include your social sharing link!
  • Be Aware of Common Pitfalls: Address trust issues, understand customer needs, communicate effectively, handle objections, follow up consistently, and differentiate offerings.
  • High-growth organizations maintain an average of 16 touchpoints per prospect over a 2–4-week period.

Want more info? Check out these data driven resources and best practices on lead management!

PRO TIP!

Remember: it often takes persistence—60% of ‘customers’ say no 4 times before saying yes.

Representatives reach 50% of leads after the 5th attempt; persistence pays off. Studies found that repeated interactions with prospects positively influence their perception of the salesperson and the organization, fostering trust and credibility.

WHAT SHOULD I INCLUDE IN MY FOLLOW UP?

How can you reach out in a meaningful way? We’ve got you covered! As you continue to nurture your leads, select AYA resources to share based on the family’s background and interests. Don’t have much info on the family? No problem! AYA has several general interest resources that apply to all families.

For a full directory of AYA’s digital resources, check out our video resource guide and keep it handy!

Share a video from our YouTube channel or an article from our blog!

For example, a hosting FAQ video or a blog article about why host families are volunteers.

Announcements

Got big news? …Share it! AYA’s Student of the month, news from our social media pages, cluster events, etc!

Local happenings

Are you hosting a booth or table at an upcoming event in your community? Planning an amazing Host Family Day? Invite your leads to join you. “Stop by the AYA booth at the Springfield Fest and check us out!

Videos

AYA’s YouTube Channel is packed with quick, informative videos on topics that may interest your leads!  For example, this video on shattering stereotypes.

Share matching info

Tell leads we have a robust pool of applicants, with a variety of interests and backgrounds – if you know they are interested in specific countries, highlight a one or two special students, and let them know that if they login to their host family portal they can save their “favorite” students and even request to host straight from their portal!

Social media

Did you see an AYA Facebook or Instagram post that tugged at your heartstrings? Share that arrival video, holiday goodness, or cultural exchange moment with your leads. Need a refresher on how to share a post – we’ve got you covered here!

Cluster updates

Fun cluster meeting? Special holiday activity? Volunteer effort? Share it!

References

Offer to put the lead in touch with a current happy host family (make sure you have a Host Family Ambassador on board!).

Seasonal/Holidays

Holidays are an easy, organic reason to reach out to leads. Wish folks a happy Mother’s Day, July 4th, or even “back to school” season!

PRO TIP!

Have a lead who is still on the fence but engaged? Offer to meet your leads for info sessions at a coffee shop or other local space, to draw a distinction in purpose from a home visit down the road.

Ask Again!

It works – it really does!

Staying engaged with leads and current/former host families, and continuing to ask them to host again, even if they’ve previously declined, is crucial for maximizing recruitment success. Research shows that customers often change their minds over time, especially when they feel valued and connected to the organization.

By maintaining regular communication, showing appreciation for past interactions, and respectfully continuing to extend invitations to participate, Local Coordinators can capitalize on changing circumstances and preferences among leads and host families, ultimately driving higher participation rates and program success.

AYA host family with a welcome sign.

FUN STATS

  • Persistence works – Harvard says so! A study by Harvard Business Review found that organizations that persistently follow up with leads are 9 times more likely to convert them compared to those who don’t follow up consistently.
  • “Mere Exposure Effect’: Research in behavioral psychology highlights the phenomenon of “mere exposure effect,” which suggests that people tend to develop a preference for things simply because they are familiar with them. This effect implies that repeated exposure and engagement can lead to increased receptiveness and openness to new ideas or offers.
  • Consistent Findings: Many studies in marketing and sales show that follow-up and persistent engagement can lead to changed perceptions and decisions. Research consistently reports that 80% of conversions happen on the fifth to twelfth contact with a potential customer, indicating the importance of ongoing engagement and nurturing.
  • Minds can and often do change: Analysis of customer relationship management data often reveals patterns where individuals who were initially uninterested or declined offers eventually convert into customers or participants after receiving consistent and personalized follow-ups over time.
  • Research has shown that an individuals’ decisions are influenced by situational factors and context, emphasizing the importance of ongoing engagement to capitalize on shifting perspectives.
  • Bottom Line – a “NO” now can be a “YES” later!

MANAGING YOUR LEADS IN THE LC PORTAL

Your LC portal is designed to streamline your workflow and help you manage your leads! Regularly updating your Lead portal is crucial for staying organized and maximizing your impact! By leaving detailed notes, you keep our team in the office informed about your progress and ensure seamless coordination. Plus, adding any new leads you’ve recruited ensures you receive proper credit for your efforts. Effective portal use allows us to keep communication channels clear and our records up to date for smoother operations and greater success!

It’s essential to familiarize yourself with its features and check it daily to maximize its benefits. By staying engaged with the portal, you’ll be able to track your progress effectively, and never miss an opportunity to connect with potential host families.

Want to learn more about how to make the most of the Lead portal? Access a demo of its features by visiting the Lead Management training module in the training section of your LC portal.

MOTIVATION

Motivation is a powerful force that guides human behavior and influences individual actions within social contexts. Exploring key motivational factors identified by researchers can provide valuable insights into the decision-making process. These factors not only impact personal choices but also play a pivotal role in nurturing altruism, community engagement, and goal achievement. Understanding these motivators is helpful when developing your outreach and engagement strategy. Below are a few key motivators to consider:

Empathy and Altruism

Research in social psychology has explored empathy in promoting altruistic behavior. The idea is that individuals are more likely to help others when they feel empathetic towards them.

Potent Calls to Action

Action-oriented language, which emphasizes taking tangible steps towards a goal, draws upon principles of behavioral activation and goal-setting theory. Setting specific, actionable goals increases motivation and performance.

PRO TIP!
PROMOTE THE BENEFITS OF ALTRUISM

• Engaging in altruistic behaviors, such as hosting exchange students, leads to greater life satisfaction and fulfillment.

• Research has shown that volunteerism and altruistic acts are associated with improved mental well-being and a sense of purpose, providing intrinsic motivation for host families to participate in the program.

Continue to Section 3: